What you need to know
- M1 Mac users are reporting extremely troublesome health readings from their SSDs.
- The TBW (total bytes written) figures show the life spans of these hard drive scould be in real danger.
- There is hope however that a software bug is behind the issue.
There are numerous reports from M1 Mac users that macOS is giving out worrying hard drive health reports which could indicate severe life span problems.
From the LTT forums:
Some more professional users of the new M1 Macbooks are experiencing extremely high drive writes over relatively short time.The most severe cases have "consumed" about 10-13% of the maximum warrantable TBW value of the SSDs (given their capacity & using values for equivalent market-available NVMe drives).
2TB 16GB model. 3% used.
That means that for a 256GB model, proportionally, you'd expect ~30% usage.
If this is accurate, some of these machines aren't going to last half a year to 100%.
And that's a 16GB model. 8GB should be worse.
Holy shit. https://t.co/9HcmaYgJPT2TB 16GB model. 3% used.
That means that for a 256GB model, proportionally, you'd expect ~30% usage.
If this is accurate, some of these machines aren't going to last half a year to 100%.
And that's a 16GB model. 8GB should be worse.
Holy shit. https://t.co/9HcmaYgJPT— Hector Martin (@marcan42) February 15, 2021February 15, 2021
M1 Mac SSD update…
Apple, this is NOT okay. Especially as the internal SSD isn’t replaceable. The machine is just a bit over 2 months old. pic.twitter.com/xqlSMjxwTaM1 Mac SSD update…
Apple, this is NOT okay. Especially as the internal SSD isn’t replaceable. The machine is just a bit over 2 months old. pic.twitter.com/xqlSMjxwTa— Longhorn (@never_released) February 13, 2021February 13, 2021
The issue of 'TBW', or total bytes written, refers to the lifespan of an SSD. As explained by PC Gamer:
Core to what's going on is the way in which SSDs work, specifically the number of writes they can reliably support. The flash memory on the drives can only be written to a certain number of times before becoming unstable. There are plenty of systems in place to spread the load across all the memory cells, but essentially there's a point where the drive has been written to so many times that it can no longer reliably hold the information.This is all summed up by the Total Bytes Written figure, measured in terabytes (which is why it's also referred to as Terabytes Written). This needs to be considered in the context of the length of the warranty, which is generally five years.
If the readings being given out from these machines is correct, developer Hector Martin says it could indicate that some machines "aren't going to last half a year":
2TB 16GB model. 3% used.
That means that for a 256GB model, proportionally, you'd expect ~30% usage.
If this is accurate, some of these machines aren't going to last half a year to 100%.
And that's a 16GB model. 8GB should be worse.
Holy shit. https://t.co/9HcmaYgJPT2TB 16GB model. 3% used.
That means that for a 256GB model, proportionally, you'd expect ~30% usage.
If this is accurate, some of these machines aren't going to last half a year to 100%.
And that's a 16GB model. 8GB should be worse.
Holy shit. https://t.co/9HcmaYgJPT— Hector Martin (@marcan42) February 15, 2021February 15, 2021
Martin does however state this is "definitely" a bug, however its unclear if that relates to the readings being given, or macOS behavior which is causing the readings to be abnormally high (but accurate). As PC Gamer notes in its report, smart monitoring tools "are notorious for misreporting" and this could be an M1 teething problem.
An update from Hector last week noted M1 SSD isn't proportional to driver size, so the "less than one-year" scenario is very unlikely:
Update on M1 SSD wear issue: Available data suggests that write endurance ratings are not proportional to drive size.
256GB model: ~2000TB [1700-2300]
2TB model: ~5000TB [4300-6000]
This means that @david_rysk's currently known worst case would push a 256GB model to 100% in ~2yUpdate on M1 SSD wear issue: Available data suggests that write endurance ratings are not proportional to drive size.
256GB model: ~2000TB [1700-2300]
2TB model: ~5000TB [4300-6000]
This means that @david_rysk's currently known worst case would push a 256GB model to 100% in ~2y— Hector Martin (@marcan42) February 16, 2021February 16, 2021
Martin described this as "still way too fast, but not as bad as we previously thought". Martin further notes that the problem isn't exclusive to the M1 Mac, and that some Intel users have also been seeing strange readings. Most recently, Dan Seifert on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/dcseifert/status/1364206594117038087?s=20
Seifer noted the issue was "all swap" caused by a 'Hand Mirror' app, and that closing it meant he could watch his SSD "reclaim free space in real time".
SSDs can continue to operate once the TBW limit is reached, however, there is no guarantee as to how long it can last. As such, Apple will no doubt be working on a fix for this in macOS, either to fix faulty readings or to rectify the behavior behind them.
